UNCTarheels
05-20-2009, 09:26 AM
HERE WE GO AGAIN!!!
Hold off on doing the around-the-world-360 with your eyeballs when you read about Howie Arons' boys vs. girls rant, because the longtime boys tennis coach at Cardozo in the PSAL isn't entirely wrong.
The Daily News (http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/high_school/2009/05/19/2009-05-19_cardozo_tennis_coach_questions.html#ixzz0Fz8BzG S5&A) reports top-seeded Beacon beat Cardozo for the PSAL boys 'A' crown at the Billie Jean King National Tennis Center on Friday. The score was 3-2, and the decisive point came from senior Hannah Berner, who plays alongside the boys because the Manhattan school doesn't have a girls team.
First things first: Berner is absolutely entitled to participate, both by the rule of law and the rule of common sense. As is the case with a lot of metro New York players, she has a national ranking — No. 11 in the USTA's Eastern standings for girls ages 18 and under — and should have a chance to show off her ability in scholastic sports just like numerous other ranked players in the PSAL.
But there is a bigger issue going on here.
"She's a girl on a boys team," Arons told the paper. "They should have a girls team. They need a girls team."
Yes, they do need a girls team. Cardozo has a girls team, and the squad won the PSAL girls championship in the fall with the help of Leighann Sahagun, ranked No. 2 in the USTA girls Eastern 16-and-under group. If Cardozo didn't have a girls team, she could have been picking up a crucial point somewhere in the boys lineup on Friday.
Beacon coach Bayard Faithfull said his school has asked for permission to field a girls team, but the PSAL told the paper that the lack of access to courts for practice and matches in the fall is an issue.
Which begs the question: If someone's scaring up court time for the boys in the spring, why can't it be done for the girls in the fall?
John Moriello's NYSSWA blog (http://www.newyorksportswriters.org/blog/blog-2009-05-19.shtml)
Hold off on doing the around-the-world-360 with your eyeballs when you read about Howie Arons' boys vs. girls rant, because the longtime boys tennis coach at Cardozo in the PSAL isn't entirely wrong.
The Daily News (http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/high_school/2009/05/19/2009-05-19_cardozo_tennis_coach_questions.html#ixzz0Fz8BzG S5&A) reports top-seeded Beacon beat Cardozo for the PSAL boys 'A' crown at the Billie Jean King National Tennis Center on Friday. The score was 3-2, and the decisive point came from senior Hannah Berner, who plays alongside the boys because the Manhattan school doesn't have a girls team.
First things first: Berner is absolutely entitled to participate, both by the rule of law and the rule of common sense. As is the case with a lot of metro New York players, she has a national ranking — No. 11 in the USTA's Eastern standings for girls ages 18 and under — and should have a chance to show off her ability in scholastic sports just like numerous other ranked players in the PSAL.
But there is a bigger issue going on here.
"She's a girl on a boys team," Arons told the paper. "They should have a girls team. They need a girls team."
Yes, they do need a girls team. Cardozo has a girls team, and the squad won the PSAL girls championship in the fall with the help of Leighann Sahagun, ranked No. 2 in the USTA girls Eastern 16-and-under group. If Cardozo didn't have a girls team, she could have been picking up a crucial point somewhere in the boys lineup on Friday.
Beacon coach Bayard Faithfull said his school has asked for permission to field a girls team, but the PSAL told the paper that the lack of access to courts for practice and matches in the fall is an issue.
Which begs the question: If someone's scaring up court time for the boys in the spring, why can't it be done for the girls in the fall?
John Moriello's NYSSWA blog (http://www.newyorksportswriters.org/blog/blog-2009-05-19.shtml)